BOGOR (TROBOSLIVESTOCK.COM). The Indonesian Independent Smallholder Farmers Association (PERMINDO) considers that government policies on food prices need to be viewed holistically from upstream to downstream, particularly for poultry commodities.
This follows the issuance of Circular Letter of the Head of the National Food Agency Number 457 of 2026 concerning the Imposition of Sanctions for Violations of HPP, HAP, HET, and SPHP prices, which includes chicken eggs and chicken meat, among other products. The circular letter affirms the obligation of business actors to comply with HPP, HAP, and HET, and allows for administrative sanctions and criminal proceedings if violations are found.
PERMINDO Chairperson Kusnan said that, from the perspective of smallholder farmers, an issue requiring serious attention is the difference in the nature of price protection for production inputs and farmers’ output.
“If we look at this policy from upstream to downstream, broiler DOC is assigned clear figures, namely a floor price of Rp6.500 and a ceiling price of Rp7.000 per chick at the farmer level. Meanwhile, the HAP for broiler chicken meat is listed at Rp25.000 per kilogram at the producer level. The question is, what protection mechanism is in place when the price of live chickens at the farmer level falls far below their production costs?” Kusnan said.
In the appendix to Circular Letter Number 457 of 2026, broiler DOC has a floor price of Rp6.500 and a ceiling price of Rp7.000 per chick at the farmer level, while broiler chicken meat is listed at Rp25.000/kg on the producer side and Rp40.000/kg on the consumer side. Broiler eggs are listed at Rp26.500/kg on the producer side and Rp30.000/kg on the consumer side.
According to PERMINDO, the issue is not the existence of DOC regulations. Rather, certainty on the breeding side is needed to ensure the industry's sustainability.
The question is whether that protection also works effectively when DOC becomes live chickens and the main source of income for smallholder farmers.
“There should be no paradox: DOC has a floor and a ceiling, while live chickens, the farmers’ output, face price volatility without an effective protection mechanism when prices fall below HAP or even HPP,” he said.
Not Pitting Breeding Against Farmers
“Breeding must be healthy, farmers must be able to make a living, the industry must be sustainable, and the public must continue to have access to affordable animal protein. What we are concerned about is the balance in the distribution of risk across the business chain,” he said.
PERMINDO draws a fundamental distinction between prices set using floor and ceiling instruments and reference prices that require implementation mechanisms on the ground.
“Do not stop at regulatory figures. When the government sets HAP, it must be clear who conducts oversight, who intervenes, how the absorption mechanism works, and what happens when farmers’ prices fall below HAP or even below HPP,” Kusnan said.
Sanctions Must Go Hand in Hand with Protection
PERMINDO also draws attention to the substance of Circular Letter Number 457 of 2026, which strengthens compliance enforcement. The circular provides for administrative sanctions in the form of written warnings, fines, recommendations to revoke permits, permit revocation, and the withdrawal of food from circulation. Under certain circumstances, violations containing elements of a criminal offense may be referred to investigators, with a penalty of imprisonment for up to seven years and a fine of Rp1,5 billion.
“We certainly support the enforcement of regulations. But compliance enforcement must be carried out fairly and proportionately across the entire business chain, not merely in a way that is easiest to apply to the smallest and most vulnerable operators,” Kusnan stressed.
In his view, small-scale people’s farmers with small populations should not be easily targeted for inspections and enforcement while compliance by large businesses throughout the supply chain receives no equally rigorous oversight.
“The rules must not be harsh downward and lenient upward. If the government wants to build compliance, all businesses must be subject to the same oversight standards, in accordance with their respective authority and roles,” he said.
PERMINDO: The State Must Be Present When Prices Fall
PERMINDO believes that the existence of HAP will be more meaningful if accompanied by an operational mechanism capable of maintaining market balance.
Kusnan said that people’s farmers need more than just a reference figure. They need certainty when prices fall, while production costs still have to be paid.
“Farmers still have to buy DOC, feed, medicine and vaccines, pay for labor, electricity, water, housing, and other operating costs. These costs do not automatically fall when the price of live chickens drops,” he said.
Therefore, PERMINDO is urging the government to clarify the mechanisms for monitoring, intervention, absorption, and protection for farmers when the live chicken price is below the HAP, and especially when it is below production costs or HPP.
“Farmers do not just need a good-looking figure in the regulations. They need certainty that when prices fall, the state will be there,” said Kusnan.
PERMINDO hopes that the implementation of food price policies going forward will not focus solely on administrative compliance, but will also be able to create a healthy, fair, and sustainable poultry ecosystem.
“Price policies upstream must not provide certainty to owners of large capital while the risks of price volatility downstream are instead borne by smallholder farmers, who have the most limited capital.”
PERMINDO advocates one simple principle: regulations must provide certainty for every link in the chain—breeding must be reasonably protected, farmers must receive effective economic protection, the industry must remain sustainable, and consumers must have access to animal protein at affordable prices.ramdan
PERMINDO | Indonesian Independent Smallholder Farmers Association